# Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace: Which Suits a New Orleans House?

> How a heat pump and a gas furnace compare for a New Orleans house: comfort, backup heat, ducts, wiring, the gas line and a fair running-cost comparison.

URL: https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-vs-gas-furnace/

What changes when a house heats with a heat pump instead of gas, when keeping a sound furnace makes sense, and how to compare the two without a guessed saving.

Old horizontal gas furnace and flue in a Broadmoor attic.

Last updated: November 18, 2026

The short answer

A gas furnace burns fuel to make heat; a heat pump moves heat from outdoor air and also does the cooling. In a cooling-heavy climate, one heat pump can replace both the furnace and the air conditioner, with an electric strip or the existing furnace as backup. Your ducts, panel, gas line and rates decide which setup fits.

Key takeaways

- A heat pump heats and cools; a furnace only heats and still needs an air conditioner beside it.
- Heat pump supply air is milder and runs longer; furnace air is hotter in shorter bursts.
- A sound furnace can stay as backup in a dual-fuel setup.
- Converting means capping gas, removing the flue and adding circuits, each as its own line.
- Compare running costs from your own electric and gas rates with the same house on both sides.

In a house heated by gas, the furnace usually shares its blower and ducts with a central air conditioner. When either one fails, the question comes up: replace like for like, or move to a heat pump that does both jobs. The answer depends on the house, the equipment that is still sound, and your rates.

[Sweet Olive](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/) installs ducted heat pumps across New Orleans, including [conversions from gas furnaces](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/heat-pump-conversion/). We install a new gas furnace only as the backup half of a [dual-fuel system](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/dual-fuel-heat-pump-systems/), not as a standalone replacement, so this guide compares the two honestly and explains when keeping or adding a furnace as backup makes sense. Our [sizing guide](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-sizing/) covers capacity.

## How each one makes heat

The difference starts with where the heat comes from.

Gas furnace

Burns natural gas in a heat exchanger and blows air across it.

- Hot supply air in shorter runs
- Needs a gas line, venting and combustion air
- Heats only; cooling needs a separate air conditioner and coil

Heat pump

Moves heat from outdoor air into the house with a refrigerant circuit.

- Warm supply air in longer, steadier runs
- Needs circuits for the outdoor unit, air handler and heat strip
- Heats and cools with the same equipment

In a climate where cooling runs most of the year, one machine for both seasons is the heat pump's main appeal.

An outdoor heat pump unit, which replaces the outdoor air conditioner in a conversion.

### Why the climate tilts the choice

New Orleans winters are short and mild on average, with a January average daily temperature of 54.3°F at the airport in National Weather Service climate normals. The heat pump spends most of its year cooling and removing moisture, and heats on the mornings that need it. Cold snaps still come, which is why every heat pump here has backup heat, as our [cold-weather guide](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-cold-weather/) explains.

## Side by side for a New Orleans house

The practical differences that decide which setup fits your house.

| What changes | Heat pump with electric backup | Gas furnace with central air | Dual fuel: heat pump with the furnace kept |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Equipment | Outdoor heat pump, air handler with heat strip | Furnace, cooling coil, outdoor condenser | Outdoor heat pump, matched coil on the existing furnace |
| Heating feel | Warm, long runs | Hot, short runs | Heat pump most of the time, furnace in the cold |
| Backup heat | Electric strip sized to the heating load | The furnace itself | The furnace, at a changeover temperature set in the controls |
| Gas and venting | Gas branch capped, flue removed or sealed | Gas line, flue and combustion checks stay | Gas line, flue and combustion checks stay |
| Electrical | New circuits for the air handler and strip | Furnace and condenser circuits | Outdoor circuit added; furnace circuit stays |
| Running cost | Electric rate only | Gas rate for heat, electric for cooling | Both, split by the changeover point |

How a heat pump, a gas furnace with central air, and a dual-fuel setup compare in a New Orleans house.

### Keeping a sound furnace

If the furnace is in good condition and its cabinet can take a matched coil, keeping it as backup in a dual-fuel system avoids a large heat strip and keeps gas heat for the coldest mornings. It also keeps the gas line, the flue and the combustion checks. Our [dual-fuel guide](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/dual-fuel-heat-pump-systems/) covers the controls and the changeover point.

An air handler in a closet, the same space a furnace often occupies before a conversion.

## What a conversion involves

Moving off gas changes more than the box in the closet. Each change is its own line in the estimate.

The lines a conversion adds

- **Gas.** The furnace’s branch is capped, with the rest of the house’s gas appliances left as they were.
- **Venting.** The flue is removed or sealed, unless another appliance still uses it.
- **Electrical.** New circuits for the air handler and heat strip, and any panel work as a separate line; see the [electrical readiness guide](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-electrical-readiness/).
- **Ducts.** Tested for leakage and static pressure, since cooling airflow now runs through the same air handler.
- **Controls.** A thermostat set up for a heat pump, its stages and the backup heat.
- **Permit.** As the estimate states for your address.

A wall control set up for a heat pump with backup heat replaces the old furnace thermostat.

Ducts built for a furnace and air conditioner can serve a heat pump once they test well.

### Why the replacement range isn't automatically the conversion price

Our typical range for a residential replacement covers the equipment and the usual work around it. A conversion adds the gas, flue and electrical lines, so it is priced from the visit like any other job. Our [cost guide](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-cost/) shows how the parts of a price add up, and the [ductwork guide](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-ductwork/) explains the duct tests.

## Comparing what each costs to run

A fair comparison uses your rates and the same house on both sides, and it ends in an estimate, not a promise.

### What we put on each side

Your electric rate from your Entergy New Orleans bill and tariff, your gas rate from your gas utility’s bill, the heating and cooling loads from the load calculation, and the equipment’s ratings: AFUE for the furnace, SEER2 and HSPF2 for the heat pump. The same indoor temperatures and the same habits go on both sides.

### What we leave out

A savings figure we can’t support. Rates change, habits differ, and the ducts can matter as much as the equipment. Our [operating cost guide](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-operating-cost/) explains the method, and the rebate on a qualifying replacement is in the [rebate guide](https://sweetolivenolaheatpumps.com/guide/heat-pump-rebates/).

A porch shading the front rooms; the house's loads are the same whichever fuel heats it.

## Three more questions

### Can I keep a gas water heater and stove if the heating moves to a heat pump?

Yes. The heating change affects the furnace's branch of the gas line only. The water heater, range and any other gas appliances keep their own connections and the gas service stays. The estimate states where the furnace's branch is capped and that the remaining appliances are left as they were.

### Does a heat pump remove the carbon monoxide risk from heating?

From the heating system itself, yes, because a heat pump burns nothing and has no flue gases. Any gas water heater, range or fireplace left in the house still burns fuel, so keep carbon monoxide alarms where they are and keep those appliances serviced. A dual-fuel system keeps the furnace, so its combustion checks continue.

### What happens to the old outdoor air conditioner in a conversion?

It comes out. The heat pump's outdoor unit takes its place and does the cooling as well as the heating. Before the old unit is disconnected, its refrigerant is recovered into a cylinder rather than vented, and the unit is hauled away. Removal is a line on the estimate, along with the furnace, the gas branch and the flue.
